Invalid Report against StarGazingNight

Name of Staff/Player:

StarGazingNight​

Steam ID of Staff/Player:

STEAM_0:1:71788788​

Your Steam ID:

STEAM_0:0:58785680​

Which Server:

East 1​

Which Map:

Dolls​

Which Round:

2 rounds before end​

Time of Occurence:

08:27AM​

Reason For Report:

RDM me for no legitimate reason all i done was push them with a crowbar.​

Evidence And/Or Witnesses:

6 "ptgamer" STEAM_0:0:213744783 55:43 78 0 active
*** Damage log:
00:02.27 - KILL: <something/world> killed Microsoft Powerpoint [traitor]
00:07.93 - DMG: StarGazingNight [innocent] damaged Ruski [innocent] for 68 dmg
00:08.02 - DMG: StarGazingNight [innocent] damaged Ruski [innocent] for 25 dmg
00:08.11 - DMG: StarGazingNight [innocent] damaged Ruski [innocent] for 25 dmg
00:08.11 - KILL: StarGazingNight [innocent] killed Ruski [innocent]​

 

@StarGazingNight to defend their self/give evidence and @Han Solo as stars admin to give the final verdict

 

Why hello there Linux and thanks for taking the time to make a report against me and sorry for the inconvenience of what has happened. Now for the reason I decided to kill you was because you crowbar pushed me next to an edge which is a traitorous act. It wasn't full blown try to push me off the edge but I saw that I was being slightly pushed closer to the edge so I decided to kill you for it.

Spoiler: Damage logs

Sadly I wasn't able to get a Death Scene recording of it and should have for evidence and the reason to as of why was because I was recording another player for hacking and blatantly RDM'ing people. (My apologies on that) And I was also screen shooting other reports for evidence as well.

I will be tagging my Administrator for the final verdict of this report. @Han Solo

 

Hi Linux, I'm sorry for this late response. I completely forgot about this report until today. I would first like to direct your attention to the extended rules on this subject:

As you can see, pushing players near ledges is defined as a traitorous act in our rules. You admit you pushed him with a crowbar, while Star says that you pushed him nearer to the edge when you did that action, which would give him a right to kill you. Unfortunately, I cannot really investigate further than this because 1) you have no evidence such as a demo and 2) Star wasn't able to get a death scene. This leads to this report being a WvW report, making it invalid.

Please message me if you have any questions,

Han Solo.