Invalid Report against Carned

Name of Staff/Player:

Carned​

Steam ID of Staff/Player:

STEAM_0:1:40186580​

Your Steam ID:

STEAM_0:1:6055869​

Which Server:

West 1​

Which Map:

TTT_community_pool_overhaul_b3​

Which Round:

3 or 4, forget.​

Time of Occurence:

3:33am pst​

Reason For Report:

Mostly to confirm for killing on sound, was a T, killed a D, ran into the changing room and alt tabbed to check something, little while later Carned kills me because he heard the shooting and "common sense" it was me because there were no doors open (the doors can be closed xD). He didn't see me do it at all.​

Evidence And/Or Witnesses:

​

 

@Carned will respond as soon as he can and his current admin in charge, @Opalium , will finish it off after his response.

 

Hey Roz.

Skip to 1:41 in this video and you can see me firstly, catch you in the killing positon and the shots coming from your direction.
And as explained in the report, the doors make sound when they are opened or closed and none of that happened.

The video shows all needed to prove that common sense was used here.




@Opalium

 

Actually, there was the door next to me that was open, you said you heard no doors open, and can't quite make out from the video whether you can hear when it does open.

 

Let me edit and up the audio to reflect what I heard.

 

Audio up as loud as I can get it, the doors is just adding onto the fact that I can see and hear you shoot as I'm typing in chat. All adds into a common sense kill.

 

Still can't hear the door open, not sure if its because stevens voice overlaps it or what, so can't really go off the whole "didn't hear any doors open or close" logic.

 

The audio is as loud as I can make it, I have gmod volume set considerably louder than it shows here.

I've proven this is common sense and will let Opal finish it up.

 

I got my sound turned up to the point that my ears won't bleed and can't hear the door open, which in a way shows that you can't go off the sound of doors being closed or open as "Logic" in this case. It was also long enough in the round for someone else to be in the room before/with me, and with the amount of places one could go, it kills the logic ideology.

 

@Opalium any decisions for this?

 

Hey Rozboon, sorry for the waiting.

As shown in the video that Carned provided, he was able to gather enough evidence to mark you as the one who made the kill. Since no doors were opened/closed in the area you were located in, the path Carned takes in the video is the only path you could've went. Doors in the game are designed to have a distinctive, noticeable sound, as they play an important role in it. After reviewing the video multiple times with the sound turned up high, I can confirm that no doors were opened/closed by you. Given the time it took Carned to reach that area, it isn't possible that someone was able to run through the room, get to the other side and close the door behind him before Carned reach it. This eliminates the possibility that someone else was there. All these factors lead to the conclusion that this is a valid common sense kill.
Therefore, I will be marking this report INVALID.

Thank you for your time.
~Opalium