Invalid Report against Bamboo

Name of Staff/Player:

Bamboo​

Steam ID of Staff/Player:
STEAM_0:1:125364850
Your Steam ID:

STEAM_0:0:20831486​

Which Server:

West 1​

Which Map:

67th way​

Which Round:

not sure​

Time of Occurence:

dont know the server crashed​

Reason For Report:

So while I was stuck behind the D room wall (the blue force field) in 67thway, there was shooting and killing going down in the outside room. As it all ended Bamboo came through the D room door (freeing me) and immediatly killing me. I reported him and his defense was "I was near Unid'ds and GBA".

Now Agent A handled my report and said the rules were clear on this situation, and I do not fault him for his position. however I would like to re-open this report in the form of a forum report.

"If a player does not have a way to see the body (i.e. a body hidden in a nearby room/behind a wall), you may NOT kill them for being near it as they are likely unaware of it.".

I feel like this situation would fall into this category. Not only was I stuck, but my camera was behind the wall, and I was unable to see any names or tell if a body was UnID'd, regardless if I could have moved or not. I find Bamboos excuse to be incredibly flimsy.​

Evidence And/Or Witnesses:

Hopefully the logs. Agent A was a witness and I would definitly like to get his opinion on the matter, even though he most likely disagree with me.​

 

Tagging @Agent A and @Bamboo to answer to this report.

 

My point of view.


I kill a player after they commited traitorous acts and such. You on the otherhand were next to an un id and witnessed the whole act, at the moment I did not reliaze you were completely stuck instead i though you just wanted in the D room. I did have a second thought of you being stuck but still I assumed you could shoot out because half of your body was out of the "detective barrier" ( This I reliazed later after murdering you) And if I known this before I killed you, I still would've killed you because it seemed like you were in a position being able to shoot still

 

Im not sure I buy that. If you thought I was not stuck why wouldn't you just shoot me on the spot, instead of waiting untill you jumped over me to open the D barrier and THEN kill me.

 

And so? This was the moment I reliazed you were near un id then it hit me he's gba kill him! If someone were to commit a t act you can mark them down and kill them at any moment within that round

 

Alright. I talked with @HelixSpiral on what he thinks on this report.
The final verdict is that this report is word vs. word.
If your gun is sticking out from the blue shield, then the verdict is the gba argument is valid and reasonable.
If your gun isn't sticking out from the blue shield, then the verdict is that the gba argument is invalid.

Now because the deathscene doesn't show whether the weapons are sticking out of the blue shield or not, HelixSpiral and I came to the conclusion that the report is word vs. word.