Denied Inkwell's Appeal

Your In Game Nickname:

Inkwell​

Your Steam ID:

STEAM_1:1:73331699​

Which Server:

EU2​

Why you should be unbanned:

For starters, I only commit tiny flaws and I do make amends (assure my mistakes) whenever I do play against the rules. I have only once before been banned and that was months ago over something as peculiar as RDM over a smoke grenade.

Second, I am not a Mass RDM:er. I have never done such a thing.

Third, I was literally only banned because the Mod who banned me didn't want me to stay over for just 2 slays he gave me, but resorted to giving me a full on ban. Not sure about this one.

Fourth, I have proof of the other mod who was on that I was forgiven for the "mass RDM", only person who died was the mod ( El Flaco Gamer ).

> Read Evidence of Innocence first, then return here. Thanks.

In short, I did RDM (killed) a person, they had forgiven me and I was grateful.

But El Flaco didn't forgive me for ruining their T-round, even though they still survived from the onslaught that particular round.

Is it fair being banned for doing something that is not even justified?

I leave this to you. Not to El Flaco, since he was fairly desperate to get me banned. I am sure of it.​

Evidence of Innocence:

Moment of the tragedy:
https://gyazo.com/ea69bd3430881dd3c7be80bc9783bb9d

When one of the other mods (mae) wanted to resolve the tragedy:
https://gyazo.com/35368bf985ba8337bc4f28ff8058c869

El Flaco Gamer took the blow that I had caused round ago to himself:
https://gyazo.com/16a271354c9a4967e9f3ac0a173a8578

Again (mae) notices it, but apparently El Flaco does not want to forgive me.
Resulting in two slays for T RDM:
https://gyazo.com/934b7846b26b5505384e14c16bbd7542

Finally, El Flaco takes the justice into his own hands, resorting to calling me out as a Mass RDM'r, even though I didn't do such a thing:
https://gyazo.com/2b4e03a365db629a9b116fedb7156cda​

 

Hello, I've seen this and am gathering my evidence. As always, thank you for taking the time to make an appeal, and a quick reminder that you're free to play on the other servers while you wait on my response.

 

First, I'd like to say I was pretty surprised and disappointed by your behavior on the servers today. As you will see, two of your report responses showed you were blatantly ignoring rules because you were upset, and the third (first chronologically) was based on rules somebody with your playtime on our severs was surely aware of.

I'll break this down into the three incidents in the order they occurred on one map which led to your Mass RDM x3 ban.

Incident 1:
As you can see, this player never entered the T room. Even though I agree that somebody with your level of experience in TTT would find the situation VERY highly suspicious, standing outside an open traitor room is NOT a traitorous act on this server. I'd also like to mention that not only were you rude in your response, you admit one of the key reasons this kind of action is not traitorous. You killed a player for something you suspected another player did. Any number of people, even through walls, could have opened the traitor door and I am very confident you knew this when you killed the victim.





Incident 2:
This one is by far the most blatant disregard for the rules and display of toxicity. Even though your response speaks for itself, I'll take the time to explain why this constitutes RDM. Both the death scene and your response show quite clearly that your killing of a fellow traitor had nothing to do with self defense. A fellow traitor killing your target is not a remotely valid reason to kill, and I know for a fact that you're aware of this one.




(Skip to 25 seconds in if it doesn't automatically take you to the timestamp)

Incident 3:
Finally, we go the the final incident which made this a mass RDM ban. Again, your response speaks quite clearly for itself. Heavily damaging a fellow traitor is not justified, regardless of what happens earlier in the round. As you can see in the video, you did 98 damage to me which is EASILY a third case of RDM.





While I will always appreciate player's right and decision to make an appeal, I'm not sure what you were expecting in this case. You yourself clearly showed that mae could not get discretion for the previous RDMs, and the option to forgive the RDM against me is ultimately in my hands. Had you not given such a poor reason on the back of a blatant and toxic RDM, I would have seriously considered forgiving. I will be denying this appeal and hope I do not see similar behavior from you in the future.

As always, feel free to PM me through the forums, steam or my discord FenSong#3339 with any questions or concerns.

 

I would like to quickly add that discord would be the best way to contact me, since I've already eaten into my lunch/study time to form this response and will be AFK on my school's campus within a few minutes.