Invalid Report against JackThePumpkin & Bio The Cornflake Homunculus

Name of Staff/Player:

JackThePumpkin & Bio The Cornflake Homunculus​

Steam ID of Staff/Player:

Staff - STEAM_0:0:77240437 The other player left "RDM and leave"​

Your Steam ID:

STEAM_0:0:58785680​

Which Server:

East 1​

Which Map:

Albatross Lighthouse​

Which Round:

First​

Time of Occurence:

11:30AM​

Reason For Report:

I removed the baby from the light house as it was next to me, I threw it off the edge randomly.

"Bio The Cornflake Homunculus" then proceeds to headshot me and kill me, i have not performed a traitors act.

JackThePumpkin also refuses to slay him as says I committed a traitors act, I believe him to be corrupt this is not the first time he/she has sided with the perpetrator rather than the victim.​

Evidence And/Or Witnesses:

00:10.00 - DMG: Bio The Cornflake Homunculus [innocent] damaged Ruski [traitor] for 54 dmg
00:10.27 - DMG: Bio The Cornflake Homunculus [innocent] damaged Ruski [traitor] for 54 dmg
00:10.27 - KILL: Bio The Cornflake Homunculus [innocent] killed Ruski [traitor]

And no Slay for the culprit.​

 

Tagging @JackThePumpkin and @Mellow

 

Tagging @Mellow as he is currently Jack's superior.

 

Alright @Linux , with all my evidence gathered it's time to get this over with.

Let's take a look at the report you've made first:

Spoiler: Report

As you can see, you claimed RDM. Biohazard in his response said that you dropped the explosive baby at some people (on the Albatross map). And as you can see on the deathscene right below, he wasn't lying:


You dropped the baby at a group of people and given the fact it's a t trap it made it a traitorous act.
Also about your other statement:

Not sure what you mean by that, but I don't side with anyone. I just punish people that are in the wrong and leave people be if they were in the right.

Now with all of that said I'll let @Mellow finish the report up.

Have a good day.

 

Thank you for posting this video it helps my case.

Just so we are clear on my action I "moved a baby prop of the roof of the lighthouse, the baby was in hand before round initiation".

It was then called as a traitorous act. However, the baby by definition is not a explosive prop such as a barrel. If this were say the first time I had had T in this map or if I were a new player I would not have known that it were a traitor trap. This is because it is meant to be a secret traitor trap, it also not possible for innocents and detectives to prove who activates such traps.

I also had a hold of the baby prior to the start of the round so letting it go was always in my interest as it would be naive of me to walk around without a gun in hand.

The act i performed was no more traitorous then moving an ammo box away from myself, just to be clear on the rule regarding explosive props it states that, "Pushing people around/getting close to players while carrying explosive props", is a traitors act noting about dropping a baby prop of a roof.

I hope you and your superiors understand this and take respective action.

 

Hey @Linux, thanks for taking the time to report my moderator @JackThePumpkin.

Basically what happened was that a person killed you for dropping the baby on top of a group from above (from the tower on Albatross). Now this exact action is indeed traitorous, as the baby goes under the following rule:



Now the rule says approaching, but any kind of throwing/dropping/bringing an explosive prop is considered a T-act and the person in question had every right to kill you, therefore Jack acted correctly by not slaying the person.

Due to all of this I will be denying this report on him as he had not done anything wrong by not slaying the player.

If you have any further questions regarding my verdict feel free to start a conversation with me.

Report: Invalid
Thread: Locked